20th Maine Flag














1st Division    5th Corps





About the Book

     Who Would Not be a Soldier! is the story of two nineteen year old farmers from Aroostook County, Maine who are shocked when the Confederates fire upon Fort Sumter and force its evacuation. Soon southern states begin to secede from the Union. Mansfield Ham and Gustavus Walker want to go fight but they have issues. They are needed on their small family farms for planting and digging potatoes. Mans has a sister with a serious behavioral problem and he wonders how his mother could run the farm and take care of her and the other children. His younger brother, Hub, is less than reliable. Gus applies some not so subtle pressure to enlist. A year passes but when President Lincoln issues a call for 300,000 soldiers in July 1862, they go.

     Their regiment, the 20th Maine, and is initially commanded by Colonel Adelbert Ames, who is a hard taskmaster. He turns a regiment of independent thinkers into an effective fighting unit. When the regiment is laid low by a medical error, Ames resigns and his second-in-command, Lieutenant Colonel Joshua Lawrence Chamberlain takes over. Chamberlain is a professor at Bowdoin College who was offered a two year leave of absence to study foreign languages in Europe. Instead he sought a commission in a Maine regiment. He develops into a skilled practitioner of military arts. He leads the 20th Maine to victory at the Battle of Little Round Top and earns the respect of top Union officers and the whole nation.

The Reader

This book will appeal to the young adult reader (12-17) with an interest in history, the Civil War and the 20th Maine. This story has been carefully researched. The endnotes have been expanded to describe how the facts were documented using both the internet and primary sources, and how readers can do the same. Whenever feasible, research protocols they might pursue are suggested.

Teachers, school librarians, and persons involved in assessing young adult books for library systems will find it to be a good story. It covers many issues of this period: slavery, patriotism, states' rights, the small farm as an economic unit, and the availability of information in 1860.


Book Review Excerpts from Book